I first encountered the term Weirding Way in regards to the martial art of the Bene Gesserit of the Dune Saga. The name has a special interest because when the roots of the words are traced back, Weirding way literally means "path to control fate", which was in effect what the BG were really trying to do with their breeding programs. Part of this martial art, which was the basis for the Jedi powers in Star Wars, was the Voice (Jedi Mind trick anyone?) and the use of sound to kill, as well as being able to speed up your movements and control every muscle in your body. The Bene Gesserit were said to be able to bend the tip of their small toe without moving a single other muscle.
This of course is all pretty fiction, but most people wouldn't bother to make a connection between a fictional idea and reality, I am not among them, I personally do not believe in fiction, or more exactly I do not believe in non-fiction. Classifications like fiction and non fiction are misleading, as there are many writers who write non fiction who are wrong, either by accident or intentionally, and again many writers who disguise truth in fiction to avoid attack. Political satire is fiction, and often dismissed as such, but we relate to it and laugh at it because it is true, often painfully so.
In the movie V for Vendetta, V says that fiction can be used to tell the truth and that truth can be used to tell a lie. What is the matter if one person sees truth in fiction, and it leads to discovery? Is the discovery lessened by the fact that the catalyst of the discovery was fiction?
How many great scientific discoveries are based on dreams? Are dreams not a form of subconscious fiction? And if we are inspired by our dreams to discover or create, are our creations lessened? I think not, in fact, the truest form of inspiration is fiction, truth is not a matter of perspective, but it is unfortunately always subject to interpretation, fiction can allow us to interpret terrifying truths and maintain our sanity. For instance, was the Matrix not the exploration of man trapped within a very real illusion as he is fed off of by machines? Dispite this link to a number of ancient esoteric traditions, the fiction permitted us to analyze how we view reality and objectivity, how we feel about destiny and freewill, and all in an intertaining way, for most people, it is painful to consider these things because they cannot yet understand them.
So fiction is a good thing, but an equally bad thing today, because we all too easily dismiss fiction as something completely outside the real, it is a two edged sword, it allows us to communicate deeply with people, but it allows them to reject any truth it brings on the basis of its nature.
As a fan of Sherlock Holmes, I was turned on at an early age to the processes of deduction, which despite the fact that the stories of John Watson are fiction, they do teach an applicable process of detective work, or reason and deduction, and also that inorder to properly use these tools, we must gain deep and specific knowledge about what we wish to deduce from and reason about.
Now, I have no intention of becoming a consulting detective of any kind, though I have spent some time studying varying degrees of criminology out of love for this singular character, Sherlock Holmes, but mine is but a passing fancy in the world of criminology, I learn only those things that apply to my field of expertise, the Martial Arts.
I have spent the better part of my life trying to find an actual martial arts teacher, or martial artist. If we investigate the word Martial we find that it stems from Mars the god of war, Martial means of Mars, or like Mars. So an art that is of Mars is one that pertains to the execution of war. May I ask you briefly how many wars have been fought entirely through pugilism? How many wars have hinged on the aptitude of its soldiers in the arena of fisticuffs?
How many kicks landed does it take to win a war? Surely wars have been won or lost due to several individual non leathal Judo matches? No? Well, if the execution of war has nothing to do with Punching and Kicking, or at the least, the whole of the War does not singularly include fisticuffs, Kicking, and Judo matches, then why are they called Martial Arts?
Some might argue that they were Martial Arts hundreds of years ago when battles were faught like that.
That is simply, and utterly not so. In fact, battles of any sort have NEVER been settled, won, or lost, based on the soldier's aptitude for punching someone in the face repeatedly. It is admittedly a desirable skill to have in case one needs it, but with hundreds of archers shooting volleys of arrows at you, men on horses with spears chasing you down, dogs, traps, and armored knights bashing at you with swords that weigh more than Rebecca Stamos, your performance abilities in Kata, your knowledge of pressure points, and your stretch armstrong kicks will do exactly dick squat in a real battle.
The bow and arrow was invented more that 50,000 years ago, the spear before that. In 50,000 years, a war has hinged on the soldiers abilities in the areas of arms, strategy, and their control of personal fear, not on how well they can punch.
In China, Kung Fu and the other arts are not called Martial Arts, they are called Boxing. Now, with all due respect, as a skill, Boxing can help to save your life if you no longer have a weapon, and unarmed combat is an intergral part of military training, but it is not the most important part, and is certainly not the only part.
Judo and Karate are valid, in theory, forms of non-lethal civillian self defense. Though as they are taught today they are ridiculous shadows of their former selves. I have studied Karate, it is, as it is taught in the west, the dieing revenge of the victims of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The masters of Japan weren't idiots, they could see that any country capable of such an act was without merit, but to refuse to teach them would elicit their anger, and they would spy and find out secrets anyway. Why not just teach them a dance routine, tell them it's all a bunch of punches and blocks, and let them think they have the secret knowledge, and then they will leave us all alone.
Yes, I understand that this is a historical simplification as to what really happened, and yes I freely admit to being slanted and biased. A writer who claims to be unbiased is lieing, always. Everyone has an agenda, sometimes it is a good and beneficial agenda, and sometimes not, but bias is what we all have, lots and lots of bias.
The common misconception today is that martial arts as we define them now are exclusive to Asia, infact the answers.com version of martial arts specifically states that they are a number of asian arts. Now of course we all know that there are brazilian martial arts like Capoiera, and Russian martial arts like Systema, but few people realize that the
Scottish and Irish and other European[
1][
2]peoples have martial arts that have survived in the form of folk dances while holding weapons, that the Canary Islands have a martial art called
Juego Del Palo, a form of Jodo, the Spartans of Greece had a various intense martial arts, in fact we get the word Gymnasium from the Spartan practice called
Gymnopaedia. [See Also:
Fencing]
On top of this, all of these martial arts are suspiciously similar. For instance, the Irish and Scottish martial arts are dances with weapons intended to teach them how they are used, they also fought and practiced naked, painted themselves blue, the Spartans on the otherside of europe did the same, performing nude dance aerobics and fighting covered in oil. In the east we have Taiji, often practiced and performed to music, and in the west Capoeira which has the most fundamental integration of music and dance.
It is also suspiciously odd that all of these areas have similar techniques, one can regard training texts for Knights in medieval europe and see similar techniques found in all martial arts, from Silat and Kungfu to Ju-Jutsu etc.
The other interesting point is the use of Drums and music composed in the Pentatonic scale, Celtic and Chinese music was Pentatonic, a study of the Lascaux[1][
2] caves indicates they were used in shamanic rituals with drums identical to Siberian shamanic practices, which may indicate a link to south american shamanism and Capoeira, although a tentative one. Remember deductive reasoning, if we can safely draw a connection between drums and music and dance, and then dance to martial arts, then we can safely assume that where ever else we find identical evidence we can draw a similar conclusion. In South America we have a strong shamanic influence, we have rituals based on the ingestion of psychedlics and ritual dances, then we have a martial art centered around a muscians who is the leader playing for the warriors (followers). Therefore we can infer that there may be a connection between south american shamanism and Capoiera, just as we can infer that there is a connection between european martial arts and european/eurasian shamanic practices.
Therefore; if we have two separate occurrences that share significant clues and each lead to similar conclusions, then we can infer, tentatively, that perhaps they shar clues because they are in fact connected.
In fact, all we have are tentative connections that indicate many things but prove nothing, in fact, it almost seems contrived how splintered the martial arts is today.
Those of you familiar with the study of
ponerology will understand immediately how martial arts federations are not in any way immune to
pathocracy, in fact, due to the violent nature of what is studied, they are drawn to it. However, lacking as
pathocrats do in any creativity, we see alot of stagnation to the point of entropy in martial arts. I can count on my hands the number of martial arts masters and grand masters who are innovators in their fields and still have fingers left over.
Another serious problem that crops up is that of the internal martial arts which have for the most part been entirely co-opted by pathocratic newagers, others simply copy movements and attach a faux taoist philosophy on top in order to sell it to new age savy pseudo bohemian coffee shop rejects. Such hamfisted philosophy transplantation is tantamount to putting a Big Mac in a Whopper wrapper.
In another vein, we can trace certain esoteric traditions emerging from the Caucases region and spreading out into China and India, as well as into the northern regions, and across the ocean to the west. At the same time we see a similar effect in martial arts, although we cannot pinpoint just where it all started, we see a similar explosion pattern. We could surmise that along with esoteric practices, a certain martial way, a grouping of movements, exercises, and strategies originated in the same area and spread out influencing the world. We can also suspect that this martial art is far older than the age we believe for the ancestors of our contemporary martial arts, in fact, it may be so old, it is antediluvian.
This martial art, if it exists, would be the mother to all current martial arts, and it may very well be, if it is so closely tied as I suspect it is to Shamanic and Esoteric traditions, a Weirding Way.